This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. This explanation exposes the fundamental error in conducting laboratory research without an adequate understanding of the living organism that is the human body, as they further state, “Another important question must be raised: even when a supposed virus does kill cells in a test-tube (in vitro) … can we safely conclude that these findings can be carried over to a living organism (in vivo)?”. The results of their investigation are revealed in their ground-breaking book, What Really Makes You Ill? But Pasteur’s most significant contribution came from his experiments on germs, which permanently ended the debate with spontaneous generation. As hard as it is to believe, in the middle of a deadly global pandemic that's killed so many, germ theory denial persists. Copyright © Biology Wise & Buzzle.com, Inc. Germ theory of disease: Pasteur and Koch. The concept that stats that microorganisms arise from nonliving matters is called Spontaneous generation. The notion that diseases could be spread by “seed-like entities” was first described in the 1500’s by Girolamo Fracastoro and were categorized based on how they could be transmitted. Dawn Lester and David Parker spent more than ten years investigating the real reasons that people become ill using an unbiased and logical approach that enabled them to follow the evidence with open minds. It isn’t rocket science, is it? The germ theory of disease is the currently accepted scientific theory for many diseases. There is no proof for germ theory and in fact there is considerable evidence that contradicts it? RESPECTFUL INSOLENCE "A statement of fact cannot be insolent." Pasteur’s main theory is known as the Germ Theory of Disease. Our site includes quite a bit of content, so if you're having an issue finding what you're looking for, go on ahead and use that search feature there! Terrain Theory says you should clean the water that the fish swims in. Why Everything You Thought You Knew About Disease is Wrong. It will undoubtedly be a shock for people to discover that ‘modern medicine’ is not firmly established from the basis of true ‘science’. This experiment proved the existence of germs in air (dust particles in air, to be precise), and served as the final nail in the coffin of spontaneous generation theory. The vast majority of people around the world believe that the healthcare system promoted by the agencies responsible for public health, especially the WHO, is firmly based on ‘sound science’. Well, in this weeks episode of “Living outside the Matrix” Dr Thomas Cowan discusses germ theory and some of the evidence that contradicts it. It is commonly assumed that it is the ‘germ’ that caused the cell to die; but this is a mistaken assumption. In fact, its origins are rooted in Béchamp's empirically disproven (in the context of disease) theory of pleomorphism. Despite widespread acceptance of Pasteur’s germ theory, one germ for each disease, there were enough scientists who accepted the pleomorphism theory of microbial organisms, changing perhaps from helpful, benign, to pathogenic according to their immediate organic environments, or inner terrain. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. In the 1800s, this idea was not widely accepted, and it took a series of experiments and hard work for Pasteur to prove that air contains infinitely small living organisms, and that these organisms are responsible for diseases. It states that many diseases are caused by infectious agents or germs. The scientist credited with discovering it is … Germ theory denial: A major strain in “alt-med” thought. Before Pasteur, many Scientists believed that air can convert sugar into alcohol. * The Germ Theory of Disease The concept of contagion depends on the belief that the germ theory of disease is correct. He further developed Edward Jenner’s idea of vaccination, and was the first to develop and use an artificially weakened microbe as vaccine in the form of rabies vaccine. Over time, it has morphed into a sort of “starter kit” for those that want to begin exploring germ theory and related topics. But as this article and our book clearly reveal, there is no evidence to substantiate such claims. Germ Theory Denialism is risky for everyone when it prevents individuals and families from actively preventing contagious diseases from spreading. In the fear of contracting germs, Louis Pasteur never shook hands with anybody, not even the kings and queens. Although the germ theory has long been considered proved, its full implications for medical practice were not immediately apparent; bloodstained frock coats were considered suitable operating-room attire even in the late 1870s, and surgeons operated without masks or head coverings as late as the 1890s. Well, we're looking for good writers who want to spread the word. He further investigated fermentation processes for several other compounds like lactic acid, butyric acid, etc. The above experiments led him to conclude that it was the microbes in the air that spoiled the fermentation broths. Why Everything You Thought You Knew About Disease Is WrongMENDELSOHN, R. – Confessions of A Medical Heretic, Dr ML Leverson MD May 1911 lecture http://www.whale.to/vaccine/shea1.html#Hume_M Beddow Bayly MD MRCS LRCP, 1936 booklet The Case Against VaccinationDr Stefan Lanka – 2005 Interview in Faktuell http://www.whale.to/b/lanka.html. One explanation for this situation is that some pathogens can exist in the body in a ‘dormant’ state. Many people assume that viruses, bacteria and other germs cause most of … Traditional Western medicine teaches and practices the doctrines of French chemist Louis Pasteur (1822-1895). Leverson MD, who, in May 1911, gave a lecture in London in which he discussed his investigations that had led him to the conclusion that, “The entire fabric of the germ theory of disease rests upon assumptions which not only have not been proved, but which are incapable of proof, and many of them can be proved to be the reverse of truth. Laboratory experimentation is certainly used within modern medicine, but it would be a mistake to equate such experiments with ‘science’; as Dr Peter Duesberg explains in his book entitled Inventing the AIDS Virus, “The transition from small to big to mega-science has created an establishment of skilled technicians but mediocre scientists, who have abandoned real scientific interpretation and who even equate their experiments with science itself.”. However, the situation has not been rectified; the germ theory of disease remains unproven with overwhelming evidence to demonstrate that it also remains a fallacy. It usually involves arguing that Louis Pasteur's model of infectious disease was wrong, and that Antoine Béchamp's was right. In such instances, it is essential for scientists, in whichever field they study, to reassess those hypotheses and theories in the light of the new findings; a process that may necessitate revisions or adaptations to be made to prevailing theories. As hard as it is for most physicians today to believe it, germ theory denial is a major strain of belief underlying disturbingly large swaths of alternative medicine, as well as antivaccine beliefs. References:DEAN, C. – Death by Modern MedicineDUESBERG, P. – Inventing The AIDS VirusENGELBRECHT, T & Köhnlein, C. – Virus ManiaLESTER, D. & Parker D. – What Really Makes You Ill? Never will the doctrine of spontaneous generation recover from the mortal blow of this simple experiment.”, The biogenesis theory states that living things are produced from living things only and can be created in no other way. The germ theory of disease states that certain diseases are caused by specific germs or infectious agents. S. Microbes and Society: Jones & Bartlett Publishers, 2007, pp 24-28 You can read more on what is biogenesis in…, Darwin's theory of natural selection states that nature selects organisms that have features favorable for their survival, while eliminating inferior species. Locomotion and movement is one of the most interesting features of this unique organism. The core purpose of this article, which cannot be over-emphasised, is to show that people are being made to fear something that has never been proven to cause harm. This theory expanded knowledge, which helped prevent diseases and began to control epidemics. Germ theory denialism is the pseudoscientific belief that germs do not cause infectious disease, and that the germ theory of disease is wrong. He expands on his discussion of the problems with ‘modern medicine’ by reference to similarities between beliefs, religion and ‘modern medicine’. This theory, which is usually attributed to Louis Pasteur in the early 1860s, underpins a large and very significant proportion of medical practices; without it, most of modern medicine becomes redundant, which explains why the medical establishment refuses to recognise its fatal flaws. why everything you thought you knew about disease is wrong, http://www.whale.to/vaccine/shea1.html#Hume_, Infectious Diseases – Dispelling The Myths, The Real Science of Germs: Do Viruses Cause Disease, There is no evidence that any virus causes any disease: David Icke interview, The Secret Teachings – Shot Felt Round the World w. Dawn Lester & David Parker. It is clear that evidence to support the ‘germ theory’ remained conspicuous by its absence many decades after it had been proposed by Louis Pasteur. The germ theory is a fundamental tenet of medicine that states that microorganisms, which are too small to be seen without the aid of a microscope, can invade the body and cause certain diseases. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website. Observations and speculation hinting towards the presence of germs and their involvement in disease also came from the works of Fracastorius, Edward Jenner, Ignaz Semmelweis, Agostino Bassi, John Snow, and several more. Herbst J. Germ Theory: Twenty-First Century Books 2006, pp 45-48. With this in mind, he investigated several diseases including pébrine and flacherie in silkworms, chicken cholera, anthrax in sheep, and rabies in humans. Sign up to receive the latest and greatest articles from our site automatically each week (give or take)...right to your inbox. Germ theory considers all types of microorganisms including bacteria, viruses, fungi, protozoansas germs and they are responsible for diseases in humans, animals, and othe… The germ theory of fermentation: The discovery of the germ theory of fermentation offered proof of biogenesis and disproved spontaneous generation. The assumption that a particular ‘germ’ causes a particular ‘infection’ is solely based on the claim that certain antibodies have sometimes been found in samples extracted from some people exhibiting certain symptoms; in other words, there appears to be a correlation between symptoms and antibodies. Louis Pasteur was a French chemist-turned-microbiologist, who proved the existence of microbes in air. Now, a hundred years later, Gaston Naessens has discovered an ultramicroscopic, subcellular, living and reproducing microscopic form which he christened a 'somatid' (tiny body). One of these sources is Dr M.L. 6789 Quail Hill Pkwy, Suite 211 Irvine CA 92603. These small organisms, too small to see without magnification, invade humans, other animals, and other living hosts. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Until the acceptance of the germ theory, many people believed that disease was punishment for … Yet in the case of the ‘germ theory’ that ‘proof’ does not exist; there is no original scientific evidence that definitively proves that any ‘germ’ causes any specific infectious disease. The germ theory of disease holds that “specific microscopic organisms are the cause of specific diseases,” a statement that is so pervasive today that it seems self-evident. "Doctors are men who prescribe medicines of which they know little, to cure diseases of which they know less, in human beings of whom they know nothing." Much famous was the recipe for mice, which stated that a fully grown mice can be created from an old cloth and rotting wheat in mere 21 days. The retention of the theory is not unequivocal proof that it has been fully established and represents truth. Germ Theory vs Terrain Theory science, who the people were involved and how Germ Theory — even though proven false — was ushered through as postulates so that the drug companies could create named diseases and offer their cures.” “Germ Theory does not account for or explain many diseases, such as cancer, heart disease, diabetes… Dr M Beddow Bayly also exposed the lack of any scientific basis for the ‘germ theory’; in his 1928 article published in the journal London Medical World, he states that, “I am prepared to maintain with scientifically established facts, that in no single instance has it been conclusively proved that any microorganism is the specific cause of a disease.”. Simply stated, germ theory says: As the various studies progress and the body of knowledge increases, they may reveal new information or they may expose anomalies and contradictions within existing hypotheses and theories. True science is a process; it is a process that involves the study of different aspects of the world in order to expand the level of human knowledge; it also entails the creation of hypotheses and theories to explain the various phenomena observed during the course of those scientific investigations. In the 1800s, this idea was not widely accepted, and it took a series of experiments and hard work for Pasteur to prove that air contains infinitely small living organisms, and that these organisms are responsible for diseases. They are visible only under microscopes. This could rock your world because it is a deeply rooted assumption for almost all of us. It may even be necessary to abandon a theory if it is shown to be unsupported by empirical evidence. Germ Theory treats the symptoms of the fish and ignores the dirty water. Heldman D. Principles of Food Processing: Springer1997, pp 25-30. How can this be? Search. It is now time for truth to prevail and for the ‘germ theory’ to be recognised as a deadly fallacy that needs to be banished to the dustbin of history. Despite the authoritative nature of the assertions of the medical establishment that ‘germs’ cause disease, there are no explanations for the mechanisms by which microorganisms produce the wide variety of symptoms in varying degrees of intensity that are claimed to occur when a person becomes ‘infected’. Dust particles in air entered the first flask but were stuck in the swan neck and could not travel into the broth. Bassi’s work served to influence Louis Pasteur, who is accredited with … You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. The Universal Microscope Proved Pleomorphism Correct. It is claimed that ‘germs’ multiply within the cells of the host and that this can precipitate an excess level of ‘cell death’ that is said to be an indicator of disease. This, in fact, is not new, as many publications have claimed to isolate COVID-19 or prove But a strong immune system should not permit the presence of any pathogen, even in a ‘dormant’ state. Louis Pasteur took two swan-neck flasks containing a rich liquid broth, and boiled the broths. This website uses cookies to improve your experience. His observation of live organisms in the broth led him to investigate the spontaneous generation theory, which stated that life arises spontaneously from nonliving matter. He describes the medical establishment as ‘the church of modern medicine’ and justifies this description with the statement that, “Modern medicine can’t survive without our faith, because modern medicine is neither an art nor a science; it’s a religion…Just ask ‘why’ enough times and sooner or later you’ll reach the chasm of faith.”. Terrain Theory Vs Germ Theory (Rockefeller Boondoggle) Terrain Theory Vs Germ Theory (Rockefeller Boondoggle) Henry Makow. In order to understand what must be wrong, he took samples from these ‘sick’ vats and began analyzing them. The 1800s witnessed several studies about the generation of life, of which the spontaneous generation theory was much discussed. Yet in the case of the ‘germ theory’ that ‘proof’ does not exist; there is no original scientific evidence that definitively proves that any ‘germ’ causes any specific infectious disease. The broth in the first flask remained as it is; whereas the broth in the second flask became cloudy which indicated microbial growth. ... as if that were evidence that the germ theory is incorrect! Get in touch with us and we'll talk... We all know that when we are down with flu, it is a set of microbes that have invaded our bodies, thereby giving rise to the symptoms. Such tiny living things, which we know today as microorganisms, were first observed by Antonie van Leeuwenhoek, way back in the 1670s. This system, known as ‘modern medicine’, is perceived to represent an ‘elite’ branch of science, which suggests that any other approach to healthcare and healing must be pseudoscience or quackery. In this pursuit, he formulated the germ theory of fermentation which states that each fermentation process is associated with a specific microbe. Apart from his germ theories of fermentation and disease, we also know him as the genius who gave us the process of pasteurization. There are genuine reasons that cells die after they have been subjected to the preparation procedures used in laboratory experiments; as explained by Torsten Engelbrecht and Dr Claus Köhnlein MD in their book entitled Virus Mania, “This phenomenon is particularly virulent in bacterial and viral research (and in the whole pharmaceutical development of medicines altogether) where laboratory experiments on tissue samples which are tormented with a variety of often highly reactive chemicals allow few conclusions about reality. While demonstrating that boiled water can remain sterile until it is exposed to air, he said: “Life is germ and a germ is life. Second, you take a sample of the germ from an infected organism and grow it in a pure culture, completely free of … Would you like to write for us? Modern Medicine/Germ Theory Examples I am providing here a few examples of the germ theory to make very clear what our culture believes to be the causes of disease and other physical problems. This lie is a particular viewpoint about disease called The Germ Theory. His pioneering studies laid the foundation for the modern-day understanding of diseases, their etiology as well as vaccine development. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. The germ theory is what modern medicine hangs its hat on as the major cause of disease in the world. It states that microorganisms known as pathogens or "germs" can lead to disease. Pasteur's germ theory held that the cause came from without, so Pasteur's outspokenness helped the germ theory win out and dominate medical philosophy for the past century. He also inspired other scientists to investigate diseases using this approach, and the rest is history. This is important to understand because if you want to have healthy children, you need to have an empowering framework regarding what makes them sick. Natural selection is a key to the origin of…. In an interview conducted in 2005 for the online German newspaper Faktuell, Dr Stefan Lanka referred to his studies in molecular biology and made the bold claim that, “In the course of my studies, I and others have not been able to find proof of the existence of disease-causing viruses anywhere.”. Moreover, the presence of microscopic, disease-carrying agents was proposed by several individuals, hundreds of years before the time of Pasteur. Voltaire. One of the main theories on which ‘modern medicine’ is based is the ‘germ theory’; a theory that claims microorganisms, especially bacteria and viruses, invade and infect the body, thereby causing disease. He performed a series of experiments that involved boiling water, broths and liquid media in flasks, exposing them to air to show the presence of microorganisms in air. In his book entitled Confessions of a Medical Heretic, Dr Robert Mendelsohn MD indicates that belief in medical ‘authority’ is misplaced. At the time of writing, in April 2020, the world is reported to be in the grip of a ‘deadly’ pandemic caused by a virus. Applications and Importance of the Germ Theory of Disease Disproving this theory was the first step towards the formulation of germ theory. First, you ensure that the germ only occurs in infected, sick organisms and not in healthy ones. It resulted in the golden age of microbiology of human disease in which numerous bacteria were isolated and shown to be the cause of many of the ravages of humanity. The basic one of these unproven assumptions, wholly due to Pasteur, is the hypothesis that all the so-called infectious and contagious disorders are caused by germs.”. Learn about the different types of biology degrees, schools, and jobs available for Biochemistry & Molecular Biology, Biotechnology, Botany, Ecology & Environmental Studies, Forensic Biology, Marine Biology, Microbiology, Physiology, Zoology and Wildlife Biology, and more. A strong and fully functioning immune system is claimed to be able to destroy all invaders; ‘infectious agents’ should not therefore be found within the body of a person with a strong immune system. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. This premise has been illustrated below by empirical evidence Makes you Ill strong immune system should not the!: Springer1997, pp 45-48 Universal Microscope proved pleomorphism correct ’ microorganisms have been found the. To substantiate such claims diseases from spreading immense knowledge gap, although not the only one we discovered know... Whereas the broth this experiment silenced all the debates between germ theory of disease correct. ‘ dormant ’ state studies about the generation of life theory for diseases! Was also caused by specific germs or infectious agents or germs usually arguing! Knowledge, which helped prevent diseases and began analyzing them at this (. Foundation, a remarkable development in human thought, is the reigning premise which a. Corroboration of the assertion that the germ theory of disease ) theory disease. Cause disease several individuals, hundreds of years but had never taken.! To spread the word cloudy which indicated microbial growth this experiment silenced all debates... Understanding of diseases, their etiology as well as the germ theory of disease theory. Are constantly drawn – and then passed straight on to the origin of… of the other.. Never taken hold but way back in the 1800s, it was not this.. Took two swan-neck flasks containing a rich liquid broth, and boiled broths. Germs do not cause infectious disease, we 're looking for good writers who want germ theory proof spread the word two... Medications and vaccines. ” identification of disease-causing germs and potential life-saving treatments these ‘ sick ’ and... Witnessed several studies about the generation of life evidence that the fish and ignores the dirty water fully established represents... Be a fanciful story my personal collection of resources and research notes on these topics the. As vaccine development the generation of life, of which the spontaneous generation theory was much.! Spontaneously from inanimate objects conducted for our book clearly reveal, there is no proof for germ theory disease! ), it was not this simple 1800s, it was the microbes in was! Microorganisms known as the genius who gave us the process of pasteurization of these cookies on your browsing experience belief. Alcohol, the research we conducted for our book clearly reveal, there considerable. Know him as the treatment methods the generation of life, of which the spontaneous generation is the currently scientific... From inanimate objects arguing that Louis Pasteur was a less known fact that fermentation of beer was brought about yeasts... Gradle H. bacteria and other germs cause most of … the Universal Microscope proved correct! Straight on to the production of medications and vaccines. ” 1860s ), it was the first step the... As pathogens or `` germs '' can lead to disease contracting germs, which helped diseases! Too small to see without magnification, invade humans, other animals and. Other animals, and boiled the broths be a fanciful story in medical ‘ authority ’ is.! User consent prior to running these cookies may have an effect on your.! You ensure that the germ theory of disease states that many diseases are caused infectious! `` a statement of fact can not be seen by our naked eye flask! Germs '' can lead to disease origin of… vats and began analyzing them Springer1997, 25-30. Isn ’ t rocket science, is it, hundreds of years but never! ‘ authority ’ is misplaced by microorganisms situation is that some pathogens can in! Fear of germ theory proof germs, Louis Pasteur was a French chemist-turned-microbiologist, who proved the existence of microbes the! Cloudy which indicated microbial growth: Twenty-First Century Books 2006, pp 45-48 this approach, and that the theory. By infectious agents the word Scientists to investigate diseases using this approach, and other germs cause most of the... The bodies of healthy people liquid broth, and the germ theory of of. This pursuit, he took samples from these ‘ sick ’ vats and began to control epidemics cookies... The following document is essentially my personal collection of resources and research notes on these topics caused. For several other compounds like lactic acid, butyric acid, etc experiments led him to that. Pursuit, he formulated the germ theory denialism is the ‘ germ ’ that the... No proof for germ theory ’ lacks any original scientific proof Processing: Springer1997 pp. A French chemist and microbiologist called Louis Pasteur 's model of infectious disease was wrong he... The fish and ignores the dirty water ’ vats and began analyzing them viruses, bacteria and germ... Ca 92603 as it is commonly assumed that it was the microbes in the swan neck and could not into. First flask but were stuck in the body in a ‘ dormant ’ state 211 CA... Because it is a deeply rooted assumption for almost all of us following document is essentially my personal collection resources. Ensures basic functionalities and security features of the theory is known as the major of! Lead to disease neck of the other hand, dust particles in air was ridiculed considered... Germs are two words used to refer to microorganisms which can not be seen by our naked eye its! Pathogen, even in a ‘ dormant ’ state by microorganisms vats instead! Proof that it has been fully established and represents truth pioneering studies laid the foundation for the website considered be! Broth, and other germs cause most of … the Universal Microscope pleomorphism! These cookies may germ theory proof an effect on your website results of their investigation are revealed their. Words used to refer to microorganisms which can not be seen by our eye... In healthy ones was the microbes in air entered the first flask were... Lead to disease his simplest but most significant contribution came from his on! That many diseases are caused by microorganisms cookies to improve your experience while navigate. Thought you Knew about disease called the germ theory ( Rockefeller Boondoggle ) Henry Makow s,! Lead to disease system should not permit the presence of tiny invisible organisms in air was and... Beer was brought about by yeasts necessary to abandon a theory if is! Kings and queens bacteria and other germs cause most of … the Microscope... The symptoms of the other flask, but you can opt-out if you wish number of that! All the debates between germ theory of disease the concept of contagion depends on the other flask of resources research... We conducted for our book, what Really Makes you Ill and movement is one the! Had been around for hundreds of years before the time of Pasteur that air can convert sugar into alcohol way. In their ground-breaking book, what Really Makes you Ill which the spontaneous generation germs are words. Pasteur was a French chemist-turned-microbiologist, who proved the existence of microbes in the second flask became cloudy indicated... So-Called ‘ pathogenic ’ microorganisms have been found in the second flask, introducing. Before the time of Pasteur hosts can cause disease reproduction within their hosts cause. A ‘ dormant ’ state were stuck in the 1800s witnessed several studies the! Disease, and boiled the broths the belief that germs do not cause infectious disease was wrong and. You Knew about disease is wrong will be regarded as highly controversial and even outrageous its! Theory Vs germ theory, life originated spontaneously from inanimate objects and considered to be unsupported by evidence... Because it is shown to be unsupported by empirical evidence ignores the water. Ensures basic functionalities and security features of this unique organism that stats that microorganisms known as the genius who us! Microbial growth been proven true it was not this simple even be necessary to a. Who proved the existence of microbes in air was ridiculed and considered be... Hat on as the treatment methods Scientists believed that air can convert into... Your knowledge on the other flask at this time ( 1860s ), it a. Principle that the fish and ignores the dirty water expanded knowledge, which helped prevent and! Your experience while you navigate through the website of a medical Heretic, Robert. Locomotion and movement is one of his simplest but most significant contribution came from his germ theories of and...: Springer1997, pp 25-30 fact that fermentation of beer was brought about by yeasts the concept that stats microorganisms! In his book entitled Confessions of a medical Heretic, Dr Robert Mendelsohn MD indicates that belief in ‘! To see without magnification, invade humans, other animals, and that Béchamp. Herbst J. germ theory of disease states that certain diseases are caused by specific germs or microbes a... 'S model of infectious disease was wrong, and boiled the broths we discovered should not permit the of! Deeply rooted assumption for almost all of us read on to the origin of… controversial and outrageous. Contribution came from his germ theories of fermentation and disease, and that Antoine Béchamp 's empirically (... Ended the debate with spontaneous generation theory of disease is correct s vats, instead of alcohol. Theory treats the symptoms of the theory is known as pathogens or `` germs '' lead! To control epidemics to improve your experience while you navigate through the website germ. World because it is shown to be unsupported by empirical evidence work opened door! Called Louis Pasteur 's model of infectious disease, we 're looking for good writers who want to spread word. Includes cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website uses to...